If you’re a teen or simply young at heart, diving into a thrilling mystery novel can transport you to a world of suspense and excitement. This curated list of the top 10 thrilling teen mystery novels includes gripping plots, complex characters, and unexpected twists that will keep you guessing until the last page. Whether you’re a fan of classic whodunits or contemporary thrillers, these books promise to engage your imagination and keep you on the edge of your seat. Each title on our list is packed with not just intrigue, but also valuable lessons about friendship, courage, and self-discovery. So grab your favorite reading blanket and prepare for an unforgettable reading adventure!
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
10. Blood and Justice: A Private Investigator Serial Killer Mystery (A Jake & Annie Lincoln Thriller Book 1)
$0.00 • 4 Stars • 21615 Reviews
Dive into the gripping world of Blood and Justice: A Private Investigator Serial Killer Mystery, the first installment in the Jake & Annie Lincoln Thriller series. This captivating novel follows the frantic search for sixteen-year-old Jenny James, who mysteriously disappears, prompting her desperate mother to enlist the help of seasoned private investigators, Jake and Annie Lincoln. As the plot thickens with the discovery of Jenny’s boyfriend’s body, readers are thrust into a chilling hunt that leads the Lincolns to confront the possibility of a serial killer stalking their town. With rapid pacing, unexpected twists, and a mounting sense of dread, this book offers a thrilling ride, perfect for young adult readers drawn to mysteries packed with suspense. Key features include a compelling storyline that seamlessly combines elements of investigative work with young adult themes of friendship and courage, as well as relatable characters navigating a perilous situation. With a striking average rating of 4 stars from over 21,600 reviews, it’s accessible as a free eBook, making it an attractive grab for avid readers. Pros include the gripping narrative and rich character development, while a con might be the initial slow buildup as the mystery unfolds. Ideal for teens and young adults who are fans of detective fiction and enjoy solving puzzles, Blood and Justice is a must-read that will keep you on the edge of your seat right until the last page.
Dive into the gripping world of ‘Blood and Justice’ – unravel the mystery today!
9. The Unknown (The Unknown Series)
$6.98 • 4.3 Stars • 950 Reviews
The Unknown (The Unknown Series) takes readers on a thrilling journey through thrilling narratives and unexpected twists that are hard to put down. Perfect for teens who love mystery and adventure, this series revolves around eight kids trapped in a… well, unknown situation that mirrors their worst fears and deepest secrets. Each installment dives into various compelling plotlines—from a simulated lunar trip gone awry to the chilling possibility of a father being a serial killer. With a star rating of 4.3 and nearly 1,000 reviews, readers rave about the gripping suspense and relatable teen characters. Priced competitively at $6.98, this series is not only affordable but also rich in thematic variety, seamlessly blending romance, mystery, and dystopian elements. The stunning descriptions grip your imagination right from the first sentence, making you feel as though you’re amidst the frantic escapes and emotional dilemmas. Pros: Engaging plots that weave various themes, relatable characters, and a pace that keeps you guessing; Cons: Some readers may find certain twists predictable after a while. This series is best suited for teen readers seeking excitement, anyone who enjoys intertwining plots of friendship, survival, and self-discovery, and thrill-seekers looking for a captivating read.
Discover the mystery of The Unknown – Click for details!
8. The Arc of a Scythe Paperback Trilogy (Boxed Set): Scythe; Thunderhead; The Toll
$6.99 • 4.8 Stars • 2426 Reviews
Dive into the thrilling world of The Arc of a Scythe Trilogy with this collectible paperback boxed set, featuring the riveting novels Scythe, Thunderhead, and The Toll. Written by acclaimed author Neal Shusterman, this New York Times bestselling series offers a thought-provoking take on a dystopian future where death is no longer a certainty. Central to the plot are Citra and Rowan, two teenagers thrust into an apprenticeship with a scythe, tasked with mastering the unnerving art of killing to regulate a world free of war, disease, and misery. Each book builds upon their challenging journey as they grapple with moral dilemmas and the dangerous power structures at play. With an impressive 4.8-star rating from over 2426 reviews, this series has garnered praise for its compelling characters, intricate world-building, and exploration of ethical questions surrounding life and death. Priced at just $6.99, this boxed set is perfect for young adults and teens who enjoy gripping mysteries infused with social commentary. Pros include deep character development and a fast-paced narrative that keeps readers engaged, while some may find the themes heavy for younger audiences. Ideal for readers seeking excitement, complex plots, and philosophical reflections on humanity’s future.
Discover the thrilling Arc of a Scythe trilogy boxed set!
7. Unofficial Detective (Half-Wizard Thordric Book 1)
$10.97 • 4.4 Stars • 421 Reviews
Dive into the enchanting world of ‘Unofficial Detective (Half-Wizard Thordric Book 1),’ where magic meets mystery in a tale that keeps you on the edge of your seat! This novel follows Thordric, a half-wizard stigmatized for his dangerous magic, as he unexpectedly inherits the thrilling task of solving the enigmatic murder of High Wizard Kalljard. With captivating prose and a richly crafted storyline, readers are taken on an exhilarating journey as Thordric grapples with his burgeoning powers while uncovering dark secrets. Praised for its refreshing characters and imaginative world, this book boasts a 4.4-star rating from over 420 reviews, affirming its widespread appeal. Standout qualities of the novel include its relatable protagonist, a perfect blend of humor and suspense, and a vivid illustration of personal growth as Thordric learns to harness his magic. This gripping read is best suited for young adults and teens who revel in fantastical adventures and love a good whodunit, making it an ideal addition to any bookshelf!
Discover the Magic of Mystery in ‘Unofficial Detective’!
6. The Summer We Forgot
$9.61 • 4.3 Stars • 247 Reviews
Dive into the hauntingly beautiful world of ‘The Summer We Forgot,’ a powerful teen mystery novel that delves deep into themes of nostalgia, self-acceptance, and the often painful process of growing up. This book takes readers on a poignant journey through the reflections of high school life, exploring complex emotions tied to lost friendships and the challenges of finding peace in one’s past. With a gripping narrative style and rich character development, the author invites readers to confront their own histories—are we defined by what we remember or by what we choose to forget? Rated 4.3 stars by 247 reviews, this compelling tale is perfect for teens seeking a relatable story that encourages self-reflection and healing. Priced at just $9.61, it offers an engaging mix of mystery and poignant life lessons, making it a great choice for avid young readers or anyone grappling with their past. However, some readers may find the deeper themes a bit heavy, so those looking for a light-hearted read might want to consider this before diving in. Overall, ‘The Summer We Forgot’ is ideal for teens and young adults searching for an emotionally resonant novel that not only captivates their attention but also prompts meaningful introspection.
Discover the magic of ‘The Summer We Forgot’! Click here to explore more!
5. Two-Minute Mysteries (Apple Paperbacks)
$8.99 • 4.5 Stars • 608 Reviews
Two-Minute Mysteries (Apple Paperbacks) is the ultimate collection for budding detectives ready to take on thrilling challenges! With a star rating of 4.5 from over 600 reviews, this cleverly designed paperback features a series of short, enticing mysteries that can be solved in just two minutes—perfectly catering to the attention span of teen readers. Each puzzle involves intriguing scenarios, encouraging readers to put their sleuthing skills to the test as they race against time. The engaging storyline paired with simple yet captivating writing makes it accessible for younger audiences while still satisfying enough for adults. Priced at just $8.99, it’s a budget-friendly adventure that combines learning with fun. A notable standout is the interactive aspect—readers can pause and ponder their deductions before flipping to the back for solutions. One drawback is that the short format may leave some older readers wanting more depth in the storylines. This book is best suited for teens who love a challenge, enjoy solving puzzles, and are looking for a compact yet thrilling reading experience.
Uncover intriguing puzzles in ‘Two-Minute Mysteries’ – Click here to explore!
4. The Face on the Milk Carton (The Face on the Milk Carton Series)
$8.95 • 4.3 Stars • 2234 Reviews
Discover the gripping teen mystery novel, ‘The Face on the Milk Carton,’ which has captivated readers with its chilling premise and intricate storytelling. This psychological thriller follows Janie Johnson, a teenager who is stunned to see her own face on the back of a milk carton, labeled as a missing child abducted over a decade ago. This captivating tale delves deep into themes of identity and belonging, making it perfect for fans of popular titles like ‘A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder’ and ‘We Were Liars.’ With a stellar rating of 4.3 stars and over 2,200 reviews, readers praise it as a ‘real page-turner’ and ‘a gripper you can’t put down’ — headlines that encapsulate its compelling nature. At just $8.95, it’s an affordable choice for readers looking to immerse themselves in a suspense-filled plot packed with twists and emotional depth. The novel’s strengths lie in its character development and the intense atmosphere, ensuring that young adults and mystery enthusiasts alike are hooked from start to finish. However, some readers note that the pacing may occasionally slow, which might not appeal to everyone. Overall, ‘The Face on the Milk Carton’ is best suited for teens and young adult readers who enjoy thrilling mysteries that resonate with personal discovery and psychological tension.
Discover the mystery of The Face on the Milk Carton!
3. The Disappearance of Emily Downs
$9.29 • 4.4 Stars • 4 Reviews
Dive into the thrilling world of The Disappearance of Emily Downs by C.J. Redwine, a must-read young adult mystery that will keep teen readers on the edge of their seats! This action-packed sci-fi thriller follows Joey Barnes, a courageous young girl who defies the eerie rules of Black River Falls in search of her missing best friend and mother. With its gripping plot, this book masterfully balances suspense with strong themes of friendship and bravery, making it an ideal choice for teens who love a good mystery. The standout feature is Joey’s clever investigations, filled with unexpected twists that unfold amidst chilling secrets of her town, ensuring readers are hooked until the very last page. Plus, with an impressive star rating of 4.4 from just four reviews, it has already garnered attention for its engaging writing style and relatable protagonist. However, some readers noted that the pacing can be quite fast at times, which might leave them wanting more in terms of character depth. Overall, this novel is best suited for young adults and mystery enthusiasts who enjoy strong female leads and a balance of suspense and adventure.
Discover the mystery of ‘The Disappearance of Emily Downs’ – Click to learn more!
2. One of Us Is Lying
$8.84 • 4.5 Stars • 45218 Reviews
If you’re on the hunt for an electrifying read, One of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManus is a must-add to your collection of teen mystery novels. This gripping tale introduces readers to the Bayview Four – four teenagers whose lives spiral out of control after being the only witnesses to a classmate’s shocking death. The plot thickens as secrets unravel and friendships are tested, creating a page-turner that keeps you guessing until the last chapter. Praised for its fast-paced narrative and intricate character development, this book boasts a stellar 4.5-star rating from over 45,000 delighted readers. At an affordable price of just $8.84, it offers not only an engaging story but also exceptional value. The series doesn’t end here; it includes the tantalizing sequel, One of Us Is Next, and even a TV series tie-in edition for fans of the show. Best suited for young adult readers who thrive on suspense and intricate plots, this novel teaches valuable lessons about trust, betrayal, and the complexity of teenage life. Just be cautious—some readers note that the twists can feel a bit predictable, yet the ride is undeniably thrilling. Dive into the mystery that has captivated a generation and prepare to uncover the secrets hidden in Bayview High!
Discover the secrets in ‘One of Us Is Lying’ – Click here to learn more!
1. A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder Complete Series Paperback Boxed Set: A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder; Good Girl, Bad Blood; As Good as Dead (The Good Girl’s Guide to Murder)
$19.20 • 4.8 Stars • 3599 Reviews
Dive into the gripping world of mystery with the ‘A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder Complete Series Paperback Boxed Set.’ This collection features the first three enthralling novels—’A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder,’ ‘Good Girl, Bad Blood,’ and ‘As Good as Dead,’ penned by Holly Jackson, and is perfect for young adults craving suspenseful storytelling. Boasting a stellar 4.8-star rating from over 3,599 reviews, this boxed set captures the essence of thrilling teen mysteries. Readers join the tenacious Pip as she investigates the truths behind a long-ago crime, blending clever twists with relatable teenage dilemmas. The box set offers an affordable price of just $19.20, making it accessible for both casual readers and dedicated fans alike. With richly developed characters and unexpected plot turns, this series is particularly suited for teens who enjoy intricate puzzles and strong heroines. While some may find the pacing slow in the initial chapters, the payoff in character development and resolution is well worth it. Ideal for fans of mystery, crime, and young adult fiction, this boxed set is a must-have for those looking to lose themselves in a captivating story.
Explore the thrilling A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder Boxed Set!