If you’re looking for a page-turner that weaves together the thrill of a mystery with the fervor of romance, you’re in for a treat! Mystery romance novels blend the excitement of unresolved questions with the depth of love stories, creating an unforgettable reading experience. Whether you’re an avid reader or just dipping your toes into the genre, we’ve compiled a list of the top ten mystery romance novels that will keep you on your toes and tug on your heartstrings. Get ready to embark on thrilling escapades filled with enchanting love interests, unexpected plot twists, and unforgettable characters. Let’s dive into these must-reads that promise to keep you guessing until the very last page!
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
10. The Guest List: A Novel
$0.00 • 4.2 Stars • 109835 Reviews
If you’re in the mood for a gripping mystery romance that weaves together suspense and intricate character relationships, look no further than ‘The Guest List: A Novel’ by Lucy Foley. This Reese’s Book Club Pick captivates with its atmospheric setting on an isolated Irish island, where a wedding celebration quickly spirals into chaos following a shocking murder. The narrative brilliantly alternates between the perspectives of various characters – from the bride to the groomsmen – keeping readers guessing until the final reveal. With its clever nods to Agatha Christie’s classic mysteries, this novel intertwines themes of jealousy, secrets, and betrayal, illustrating how deep-rooted human emotions can shatter even the most meticulously planned events. Readers rave about its compelling plot and unexpected twists, reflected in its impressive star rating of 4.2 from over 109,000 reviews. However, some note that the multiple perspectives can initially feel overwhelming. Perfect for those who enjoy psychological thrillers and romantic undertones, ‘The Guest List’ is well-suited for fans of mystery who love to unravel intricate plots that keep the adrenaline pumping. Grab your copy to dive into a tale where everyone has something to hide, and nothing is as it seems.
Discover the suspense of ‘The Guest List’ – Click for details!
9. The Frozen River: A GMA Book Club Pick: A Novel
$13.50 • 4.6 Stars • 47812 Reviews
If you’re on the hunt for a riveting historical mystery laced with romance, look no further than ‘The Frozen River: A GMA Book Club Pick.’ This New York Times bestseller by Ariel Lawhon transports readers to Maine in 1789, where midwife Martha Ballard must solve the mystery of a man found frozen in the river. Drawing on the diary of the real-life Martha, Lawhon crafts a compelling narrative filled with suspense, ethical dilemmas, and a rich historical backdrop. With a star rating of 4.6 from over 47,000 reviews, this novel stands out for its intricate storytelling and strong female lead who dares to seek truth amidst societal limitations. The standout qualities include its blend of gripping mystery with themes of justice, the historical authenticity, and the multifaceted portrayal of women’s roles in early America. Pros include a fast-paced plot, well-developed characters, and engaging prose that keeps readers at the edge of their seats, while potential cons might be the slower start for some readers not used to historical settings. Perfect for fans of strong heroines and anyone who enjoys stories where love and justice intertwine, ‘The Frozen River’ is a true page-turner that will keep you guessing until the last chapter.
Discover the captivating story behind ‘The Frozen River’ – click here to learn more!
8. The Couple Next Door: A Novel
$9.90 • 4.1 Stars • 92617 Reviews
Delve into the enthralling world of psychological intrigue with ‘The Couple Next Door: A Novel,’ a gripping mystery romance that has captured the hearts of readers. With a solid 4.1-star rating from over 92,000 reviews, this novel masterfully intertwines suspense with romantic elements, creating a page-turner that will keep you guessing until the very last chapter. The story follows a young couple whose lives unravel in shocking ways after a horrible crime occurs in their seemingly perfect neighborhood. Key features of this novel include sharp, engaging writing, a well-crafted plot with unexpected twists, and relatable, multi-dimensional characters that evoke a range of emotions. Priced at just $9.90, it’s an accessible choice for both casual and avid readers alike. The standout quality lies in its ability to blend genres, making it an especially great pick for fans of both mystery and romance. Pros include the novel’s captivating pace and unpredictable plot, while a con might be its mature themes, which may not appeal to all audiences. This book is perfect for readers seeking a thrilling escape with a touch of romance, ideal for cozying up on a rainy day or taking on a long commute.
Discover the suspense of ‘The Couple Next Door’ – Click here for details!
7. The Lost Bookshop: The most charming and uplifting novel for 2025 and the perfect gift for book lovers!
$12.52 • 4.4 Stars • 124692 Reviews
The Lost Bookshop: The Most Charming and Uplifting Novel for 2025 is a must-read for fans of mystery romance novels. With an impressive 4.4-star rating from over 124,600 reviews, this captivating tale combines the allure of a hidden bookshop with a heartwarming love story, inviting readers into a world of intrigue and charm. Priced at just $12.52, it’s an affordable treasure for book lovers! One of the standout qualities of this novel is its rich character development and engaging storyline that keeps readers guessing until the final page. The book seamlessly blends romance and mystery, appealing to those who relish a layered plot with emotional depth. Pros include its relatable characters, beautifully descriptive prose, and a whimsical setting that makes it perfect for escapism. However, some readers noted that the pacing could feel slow in parts, something to consider for those who prefer a fast-paced read. Overall, The Lost Bookshop is ideally suited for literary enthusiasts who appreciate a blend of romance, mystery, and a touch of magical realism. It’s an excellent gift for anyone looking for their next page-turner!
Discover ‘The Lost Bookshop’ – the perfect read for 2025!
6. Those Empty Eyes: A Chilling Novel of Suspense with a Shocking Twist
$10.37 • 4.4 Stars • 21011 Reviews
‘Those Empty Eyes: A Chilling Novel of Suspense with a Shocking Twist’ is a gripping addition to the mystery romance genre that has captivated over 21,000 readers, garnering a solid 4.4-star rating. This novel intricately weaves a tale of love intertwined with suspense, where unexpected twists keep readers on the edge of their seats. The standout qualities of this book include its immersive storytelling, well-crafted characters, and a plot that cleverly integrates emotional depth and thrilling mystery. At a price of $10.37, this novel stands out as an excellent investment for fans of both romance and suspense. However, some readers may find the pacing slow in certain sections, while others may desire a more conclusive ending. This book is best suited for avid readers looking for a captivating page-turner that combines elements of love with an engaging mystery, making it perfect for cozy nights in or book club discussions.
Uncover the suspense in ‘Those Empty Eyes’ – click for more!
5. Mean Streak
$8.36 • 4.5 Stars • 18659 Reviews
‘Mean Streak’ by Sandra Brown is a gripping New York Times bestselling thriller that seamlessly intertwines elements of mystery and romance, ensuring readers are kept on the edge of their seats. The story revolves around Dr. Emory Charbonneau, a pediatrician and avid marathon runner, who becomes a victim of kidnapping after a fight with her husband. The novel is set against the haunting backdrop of North Carolina’s mountain wilderness, where Emory’s fight for survival begins as she confronts not only her captor—a mysterious man shrouded in violence—but also the haunting uncertainties surrounding her marriage. With a star rating of 4.5 and over 18,000 reviews, this engrossing tale explores themes of love, deceit, and moral dilemmas, leading Emory to question whether her captor is a savior or a threat. Priced affordably at $8.36, ‘Mean Streak’ is perfect for fans of psychological thrillers who crave a mix of suspense and heated romance. Pros include well-developed characters and a fast-paced narrative, while some readers may find the storyline’s complexity a bit overwhelming. It’s best suited for readers who enjoy intense romantic thrillers with strong female protagonists and unexpected plot twists.
Discover the Thrill of Mean Streak – Click Here!
4. One of Us Is Lying
$8.84 • 4.5 Stars • 45207 Reviews
If you’re a fan of thrilling mysteries laced with romantic intrigue, then ‘One of Us Is Lying’ by Karen M. McManus is a must-read. This captivating novel dives deep into the lives of four teenagers—known as the Bayview Four—who become embroiled in a murder investigation following the death of their classmate. With a gripping narrative that blends suspense, drama, and youthful adventure, this book keeps readers guessing until the very end. The standout quality of this novel lies in its multifaceted characters, each with their own secrets, perspectives, and motives, making the plot even more thrilling and engaging. Plus, the book has received outstanding praise, boasting a 4.5-star rating from over 45,000 reviews, a testament to its broad appeal and gripping storyline. It’s priced affordably at $8.84, perfect for those looking for an enthralling read without breaking the bank. Ideal for young adults and mystery aficionados alike, ‘One of Us Is Lying’ not only entertains but also encourages readers to question the truth behind appearances. However, some might find certain plot elements predictable or familiar if they are avid consumers of the genre. Overall, this novel is perfect for readers looking for a compulsively readable page-turner infused with romance and psychological depth.
Unravel the Mystery – Discover ‘One of Us Is Lying’!
3. The Love of My Life: A GMA Book Club Pick: A Novel
$10.59 • 4.2 Stars • 25777 Reviews
Dive into the gripping pages of ‘The Love of My Life: A GMA Book Club Pick: A Novel,’ a compelling addition to the mystery romance genre that blends suspense with heartfelt storytelling. With a star rating of 4.2 and over 25,000 reviews, this novel has captured the hearts of readers worldwide. Priced at just $10.59, it offers a captivating escape filled with unexpected twists and emotional depth. Key features of this book include a well-crafted plot that keeps readers on the edge of their seats, relatable characters whose journeys evoke empathy, and a narrative that seamlessly interweaves romance with tense intrigue. The standout quality of this book lies in its ability to challenge the reader to unravel the enigmatic relationship dynamics between the protagonists, making it perfect for book club discussions. Pros of this novel include its engaging writing style and well-paced suspense, while a potential con might be its slow build-up that may not appeal to readers looking for immediate action. This book is ideal for fans of romantic mysteries, those who enjoy character-driven narratives, and anyone seeking an enthralling read that prompts deep reflection on love and relationships.
Discover the heartwarming story in ‘The Love of My Life’ – Click for details!
2. Midnight Shadows
$8.41 • 4.7 Stars • 849 Reviews
Introducing ‘Midnight Shadows,’ a captivating blend of mystery and romance that will keep you on the edge of your seat. With a commendable 4.7-star rating from 849 reviews, this gripping tale follows the tumultuous relationship between undercover cop Allison Fletcher and nightclub owner Jonah Blackhawk, whose chemistry ignites even as they clash over a complex case. The novel masterfully intertwines suspense with passion, offering readers a narrative filled with unexpected twists, including the thrilling subplot featuring Bailey James, a woman with amnesia and a bag full of cash. Key features include well-developed characters, a fast-paced plot, and romantic tension that elevates the stakes. Pros include its engaging writing style and the seamless blending of the romance and mystery genres, while a con might be the cliffhanger ending that leaves readers yearning for more. Best suited for fans of romantic suspense and those who relish a tale of forbidden love set against a backdrop of danger, ‘Midnight Shadows’ is a must-read for anyone looking to immerse themselves in an unforgettable narrative.
Discover the allure of Midnight Shadows – Shop Now!
1. Then She Was Gone: A Novel
$8.81 • 4.5 Stars • 117705 Reviews
‘Then She Was Gone: A Novel’ by Lisa Jewell is a gripping mystery romance that intertwines love, loss, and the search for truth. With an impressive star rating of 4.5 from over 117,000 reviews, this captivating read promises to keep you on the edge of your seat. The story revolves around the disappearance of a young girl, exquisitely unfolding the layers of grief and the desperate quest for answers by her mother, Laurel, who navigates through a web of secrets that blur the lines between love and betrayal. Priced at just $8.81, this novel not only offers an engaging and emotional narrative but also appeals to readers looking for a well-crafted plot with unpredictable twists. Notable pros include its rich character development and a storyline that masterfully blends romance and suspense, while a minor con could be that some readers may find certain plot points a bit far-fetched. This novel is best suited for fans of psychological thrillers and mystery lovers seeking an emotional rollercoaster alongside a touch of romance.
Discover the mystery behind ‘Then She Was Gone’ – Click here for details!