Amish romance novels have carved out a delightful niche in the literary world, captivating readers with their heartwarming stories, charming characters, and unique insights into a different way of life. These books often explore themes of love, community, and faith, making them perfect for anyone seeking sweet, wholesome romance without the usual dramatic twists. In this article, we’ve curated a list of the Top 10 Amish Romance Novels that will steal your heart and leave you yearning for more. Whether you’re a long-time fan of the genre or a newcomer looking to dive into this enchanting world, these selections offer something for everyone.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
10. An Unexpected Amish Romance and The Amish Nanny’s Sweetheart: A 2-in-1 Collection
$2.99 • 4.7 Stars • 18 Reviews
Dive into the heartwarming world of Amish romance with the ‘An Unexpected Amish Romance and The Amish Nanny’s Sweetheart: A 2-in-1 Collection’ by Patricia Davids and Jan Drexler. This delightful compilation features two engaging stories that beautifully capture love and personal growth amidst the serene backdrop of Amish country. In ‘An Unexpected Amish Romance,’ Helen Zook embarks on a fresh start after her broken engagement, only to find herself clashing with her ruggedly handsome boss, Mark Bowman. Their chemistry, ignited by an unexpected matchmaking basset hound, unfolds into a journey of emotional healing and connection. The second tale, ‘The Amish Nanny’s Sweetheart,’ follows Judith Lapp, who finds herself immersed in the warmth of community life as a nanny. Her story takes a compelling twist when she steps out of her comfort zone to teach a farmworker, Guy Hoover, the beauty of Pennsylvania Dutch, leading to a deepening bond. Both stories are rich with themes of self-discovery, community ties, and the struggles of balancing personal aspirations with romantic entanglements. With a solid 4.7-star rating from 18 reviews and an affordable price of just $2.99, this collection is perfect for readers who enjoy touching love stories intertwined with the simplicity of Amish life. Pros include relatable characters and engaging plotlines, while some may find the story’s pacing slow at times. Ideal for fans of wholesome romance or anyone seeking a cozy escape into the enchanting world of the Amish.
Discover Heartwarming Tales in Our Amish Romance Collection!
9. The Amish Wedding Promise
$7.99 • 4.6 Stars • 283 Reviews
If you’re a fan of heartwarming stories that explore love amidst life’s unexpected twists, then The Amish Wedding Promise is a must-read for you. This captivating tale follows Grace Lantz, whose wedding day takes an unexpected turn when a tornado disrupts her plans. Rather than being disheartened, Grace feels a sense of relief when the unhelpful groom-to-be fails to check on her. Instead, it’s the kind-hearted Zeke Bontrager, a volunteer who came to assist the community, who steps up to lend his strong shoulders to Grace. The plot thickens as Zeke, battling his growing feelings for Grace, is determined to help her reconnect with her fiancé. As Grace faces her true emotions, readers are taken on a journey of self-discovery and the realization that true love may be closer than it seems. With an impressive star rating of 4.6 from 283 reviews, this novel not only offers a compelling storyline but also highlights themes of loyalty, love, and personal empowerment. For just $7.99, readers can immerse themselves in this enchanting world. This book is ideal for fans of Amish romance, those seeking uplifting narratives about love, and readers who appreciate a story where life’s challenges lead to unexpected blessings. A potential con is that some readers might find the pacing a bit slow in parts, but the engaging characters and their emotional growth more than compensate for it.
Discover the heartfelt journey of The Amish Wedding Promise!
8. Uncovering Her Amish Past: An Uplifting Inspirational Romance (Love Inspired)
$5.98 • 4.6 Stars • 44 Reviews
‘Uncovering Her Amish Past: An Uplifting Inspirational Romance’ is a captivating read that blends heartwarming themes of family, love, and self-discovery. This novel tells the story of Penelope Moore, an Englisch artist who unexpectedly finds herself entwined in the fabric of an Amish community in Pierce, Montana. As Penelope uncovers her hidden past and the surprising connection to her twin sister, Sarah, she is embraced by the welcoming Amish culture and its rich traditions. Written by a seasoned author, this novel excels in developing relatable characters, especially the charming bachelor Simon Troyer, who adds a romantic tension that any Amish romance fan will adore. With a star rating of 4.6 from 44 reviews, readers appreciate its uplifting message of faith and hope while indulging in the enchanting dynamics of Penelope’s journey. Priced at just $5.98, it’s an affordable option for those seeking quality literature. This book is perfect for readers who love a blend of romance and personal growth, particularly those interested in exploring the nuances of Amish life versus the Englisch world. Pros include its engaging plot and character depth, while a minor con could be the predictability of its romantic themes, typical of its genre.
Discover the heartwarming journey in ‘Uncovering Her Amish Past’!
7. Amish Christmas Blessings: An Amish Holiday Romance (Heart warming complete Amish Romance series)
$0.00 • 4.5 Stars • 105 Reviews
‘Amish Christmas Blessings: An Amish Holiday Romance’ is a captivating boxed set that brings together the enchanting ‘Christmas Blessings’ series by bestselling author Grace Lewis, which has won over readers and secured its place as an Amazon #1 bestseller in Amish Romance and Inspirational Spiritual Fiction. The collection follows the journey of Mary Richards, a lonely Englischer from Chicago, who is unexpectedly sent to the idyllic Amish community of Dalton, Wisconsin. Here, amidst the charm of snow-covered fields and Christmas lights, she meets the genuine Moses Lapp, whose simple faith and heartfelt warmth spark a transformative love. This beautifully packaged series consists of six uplifting tales, including ‘Love for Christmas,’ ‘Mary’s Christmas Miracle,’ and ‘Renewed Hope for Christmas.’ Each story explores themes of love, faith, and the power of community amidst real-life challenges, showcasing the importance of forgiveness and connection during the holiday season. Readers have praised the series for its engaging storytelling and emotional depth, providing a perfect escape into a world of holiday magic. However, some may find the pacing slow at times, and the focus on faith-based messages might not suit everyone’s taste. Overall, this series is best suited for those seeking heartwarming, feel-good stories with a strong spiritual connection, making it a perfect addition to your holiday reading list.
Discover the warmth of love this season – click here for more on ‘Amish Christmas Blessings’!
6. Amish Christmas Family Love: Bumper Christmas Amish Romance – 15 Book Box Set
$13.22 • 4.8 Stars • 133 Reviews
If you’re yearning for heartwarming tales that capture the essence of faith, love, and family during the holiday season, then the ‘Amish Christmas Family Love: Bumper Christmas Amish Romance – 15 Book Box Set’ is a must-have addition to your bookshelf. This compelling collection includes fifteen inspirational romance stories, three of which are brand new, never-before-released gems sure to enchant readers of all ages. Experience the warmth of Amish traditions and the spirit of Christmas through touching narratives such as ‘The Amish Christmas Storm’ and ‘A Christmas Promise in Pine Lake.’ With a stellar 4.8-star rating from 133 reviews, this box set promises extensive enjoyment during the chilly winter months—ideal for cozy nights by the fire. Not only is it available for FREE with Kindle Unlimited, making it accessible to many, but its rich tapestry of stories provides both escapism and nostalgia. While some readers may find that a few stories follow predictable plots typical of the genre, the overall charm and uplifting messages shine through. This collection is best suited for fans of clean romance, particularly those who appreciate stories steeped in simplicity, faith, and the strong bonds of community, making it a perfect gift for friends or family who treasure charming holiday narratives.
Discover Heartwarming Amish Romance: Explore the 15 Book Box Set!
5. Their Secret Amish Arrangement: An Uplifting Inspirational Romance (Love Inspired)
$12.99 • 4.7 Stars • 39 Reviews
If you’re a fan of heartwarming romance filled with cultural intrigue and emotional depth, look no further than ‘Their Secret Amish Arrangement: An Uplifting Inspirational Romance’. This charming novel follows the story of Henry Barrett, a contractor with a shaky past, who arrives in Hickory Hollow to renovate a house and reconnect with his estranged brother. Enter Clara Templeton, a shy yet endearing baker from an Amish community, who reluctantly agrees to a fake courtship with Henry. Their arrangement takes an unexpected turn as they discover the warmth of companionship and affection amidst societal boundaries. With a star rating of 4.7 from 39 reviewers, this inspiring tale masterfully blends themes of love, faith, and personal growth. Priced at $12.99, it offers incredible value for readers seeking a touching narrative adorned with key features such as rich character development and a picturesque rural setting. The standout quality of this romance lies in its portrayal of bridging cultural divides, making it relatable for readers who appreciate stories of unlikely connections. Pros include the engaging writing style and relatable characters, while the con may be its predictable storyline. This novel is best suited for those who enjoy clean romance with a sprinkle of inspirational messaging and a desire to escape into a world of heartfelt emotions.
Discover the Heartwarming Story of ‘Their Secret Amish Arrangement’!
4. Lancaster Bridges Boxed Set: The Complete Amish Romance Series
$16.99 • 4.6 Stars • 162 Reviews
The Lancaster Bridges Boxed Set is a must-have for fans of Amish romance, offering the complete series from #1 best-selling author Sylvia Price. This beautifully packaged collection features five full-length novels that delve into the enchanting world of Lancaster County’s Amish community. Each story highlights key themes of love, personal growth, and faith, as characters navigate the delicate balance between their traditional values and the intriguing allure of the outside world. Readers will appreciate the heartfelt narratives that not only showcase the simplicity and beauty of Amish life but also the complexities of love and relationships within a close-knit community. Notable titles included are The Bridge of Trust, The Bridge of Progress, The Bridge of Solace, The Bridge of Forgiveness, and The Bridge of Belonging. With a stellar star rating of 4.6 from 162 reviews, this set is not only a great value at $16.99 but also appeals to both longtime fans and newcomers to the genre. While the series is rich in sentimental storytelling, some readers may desire more action-packed plots, so those seeking high-drama may find it less engaging. Overall, the Lancaster Bridges Boxed Set is perfect for anyone who enjoys heartwarming tales of romance steeped in tradition and community.
Discover the Heartwarming Lancaster Bridges Boxed Set!
3. The Rise and Fall of Miss Fannie’s Biscuits: A Cozy Amish Mystery
• 4.4 Stars • 58 Reviews
If you’re looking for a captivating read that combines the charm of Amish life with a delightful mystery, look no further than ‘The Rise and Fall of Miss Fannie’s Biscuits: A Cozy Amish Mystery.’ Co-authored by the renowned Wanda E. Brunstetter and Emmy-nominated Martha Bolton, this book weaves an engaging tale set in the picturesque backdrop of Ohio’s Amish country. At the heart of the story is Fannie Miller, an amateur sleuth who, alongside retired cop Foster Bates, investigates strange disappearances during the county baking contest finals. With its unique premise, relatable characters, and a perfect blend of humor and suspense, this novel promises not only to entertain but also to keep you guessing until the very last page. Boasting a solid 4.4-star rating from 58 reviews, it has received rave accolades for its witty plot and warm characterization, making it perfect for fans of cozy mysteries and those new to the genre alike. However, some readers may find the pacing leisurely, while the deeper dive into Amish culture might not appeal to everyone. Ideal for pajama-clad readers sipping tea on a rainy afternoon, or anyone who craves a lighthearted escape filled with delightful twists and turns.
Uncover the mystery in ‘The Rise and Fall of Miss Fannie’s Biscuits’ – Click here for details!
2. Amish Romance at Christmastime: Three Novels in One Volume
$11.99 • 4.7 Stars • 279 Reviews
If you’re looking for a delightful escape into the heartwarming world of Amish romance, ‘Amish Romance at Christmastime: Three Novels in One Volume’ by bestselling author Linda Byler is the perfect choice. This collection features three captivating novellas that beautifully intertwine the themes of love, family, and faith during the joyous holiday season. Byler, an Amish woman herself, offers authentic insights into the lifestyle and culture that enrich the storytelling. In ‘The More the Merrier,’ readers follow Annie Miller as she navigates widowhood and the challenges of raising eight children, leading to a poignant friendship that blossoms into something more with a fellow widower. Another standout, ‘A Dog for Christmas,’ tells the inspirational journey of Henry, who transforms his lonely existence through love and companionship, showcasing resilience and the triumph of the human spirit. Lastly, ‘A Horse for Elsie’ tackles the complexities of teenage desire against a backdrop of community tragedy, culminating in a powerful message of hope and acceptance. With a stellar rating of 4.7 from 279 reviews, this compilation is exceptionally well-received, resonating especially with fans of cozy fiction who cherish tales of emotion and connection. Priced at $11.99, it offers great value; however, some may find the pacing slower than typical contemporary romances. This volume is best suited for readers seeking heartfelt stories that celebrate the magic of love, especially during the holiday season.
Discover the heartwarming stories in Amish Romance at Christmastime!
1. Her Forbidden Christmas Match: An Uplifting Inspirational Romance (Seven Amish Sisters, 5)
$20.00 • 4.5 Stars • 53 Reviews
‘Her Forbidden Christmas Match: An Uplifting Inspirational Romance’ is the fifth entry in the popular Seven Amish Sisters series and is a delightful addition to any reader’s collection. This heartwarming tale revolves around Aaron Raber, a widower determined to prioritize his five-year-old daughter while navigating his new life far from a stringent religious community. As fate intertwines his path with Willa Koffman, a strong-willed Amish woman who offers to babysit his daughter during his construction job, both characters discover an unexpected and budding attraction that challenges their beliefs and community ties. Priced at $20.00 and boasting a stellar rating of 4.5 from 53 reviews, this novel resonates with those who cherish uplifting stories centered around faith, forgiveness, and romance. The standout quality of this book lies in its ability to balance personal struggle with love, making it perfect for readers seeking inspiration amid adversity. Pros include its engaging writing and strong character development, while some readers may find the predictable plot arc a minor drawback. Ultimately, this novel is ideal for fans of Amish romance and anyone yearning for a touching story to warm their heart this holiday season.
Discover the heartwarming story in ‘Her Forbidden Christmas Match’ – click for details!