
A Flaw in Human Judgment
by Daniel Kahneman, Olivier Sibony, Cass R. Sunstein
- Judgment
- Decision Making
- Errors
As an Amazon Associate, Home of a Book Lover earns from qualifying purchases. Book data from Open Library.
Quick facts
| Subtitle | A Flaw in Human Judgment |
|---|---|
| Authors | Daniel Kahneman, Olivier Sibony, Cass R. Sunstein |
| First published | 2021 |
| Edition publisher | Little, Brown Spark |
| Edition date | May 18, 2021 |
| Language | English |
| Pages (this edition) | 464 |
| ISBN-13 | 9780316451406 |
| ISBN-10 | 0316451401 |
| Formats | hardcover |
| Subjects | Judgment, Decision Making, Errors |
About Noise
Where Thinking, Fast and Slow concentrated on bias, Noise turns to a second source of error: "undesirable variability in judgments of the same problem." Daniel Kahneman, Olivier Sibony and Cass Sunstein argue that noise is everywhere professionals exercise judgment. Their examples include an insurance company where underwriters' premiums for identical cases differed by a median of 55 percent, psychiatrists who agreed on diagnoses only about half the time, and evidence that French judges were more lenient on a defendant's birthday. They recommend noise audits to measure the problem and "decision hygiene" practices to reduce it. The authors trace noise to factors such as cognitive biases, mood, group dynamics and emotional reactions, and they treat bias as a contributor to both kinds of error.
Main themes
- Bias versus noise as distinct kinds of error
- Noise audits in organizations
- Decision hygiene and structured judgment
- Costs: injustice, health risks and wasted money
Key concepts
- noise vs. bias
- noise audit
- decision hygiene
- variability in professional judgment
Who itβs for
Who should read it
Managers, judges, clinicians, underwriters, recruiters and anyone responsible for decisions that ought to be consistent across cases.
Who may not enjoy it
Casual readers; reviewers found it long and uneven in style, shifting between textbook, academic and business-magazine registers.
What makes it distinctive
It names and quantifies a kind of error that most books on judgment ignore, and gives organizations concrete procedures to address it.
Style & difficulty
Demanding. Long, with statistical concepts and policy discussion.
Context
First published May 18, 2021 by Little, Brown Spark. Critics have argued that reducing noise can dehumanize the people being judged or entrench discrimination, and some questioned how new the concept is.
Strengths & limitations
Strengths
- Fills a real gap in the literature on judgment
- Actionable organizational tools
- Strong, specific examples
Limitations
- Long and stylistically uneven
- Debate over the novelty and side effects of noise reduction
FAQs
How is noise different from bias?
Bias is error in a consistent direction; noise is scatter. The authors note that noise shows up as disagreement between judges, inconsistency within the same judge, and even in one-off judgments, which they treat as one draw from a cloud of possible answers.
Who are the co-authors?
Olivier Sibony is a management consultant and professor, and Cass Sunstein is a law professor and Holberg Prize laureate who also co-wrote Nudge with Richard Thaler.
Sources & attribution
- Edition: Little, Brown Spark, first edition hardcover, ISBN 0316451401 / 9780316451406, 464 pages β openlibrary.org
- Publisher: on sale May 18, 2021; 464 pages β hachettebookgroup.com
- Noise defined as undesirable variability in judgments of the same problem; underwriters 55%; psychiatrists agreed in half the cases; French judges more lenient on birthday; noise audits; decision hygiene; critiques re dehumanization, discrimination, novelty; criticism of length and inconsistent style β en.wikipedia.org
- Cover image matches edition (visually checked) β covers.openlibrary.org
- Noise arises from cognitive biases, mood, group dynamics, emotional reactions; cognitive bias gives rise to both statistical bias and noise β en.wikipedia.org
- Noise forms: between judges, within judges, single judgments as a cloud of possible judgments; Sibony management consultant and professor; Sunstein law professor and Holberg Prize laureate β en.wikipedia.org
- Sunstein co-author of Nudge β en.wikipedia.org
Book data from Open Library.