If you’re a fan of suspense, intrigue, and plot twists that keep you on the edge of your seat, diving into the world of mystery novels is a must. Whether you’re looking for a thrilling whodunit or an unsettling psychological thriller, the literary market is rich with bestselling titles that promise to captivate your imagination and keep you guessing until the very last page. In this roundup, we’ve curated the top 10 bestselling mystery novels that you simply can’t put down. Each selection not only showcases masterful storytelling but also weaves complex characters and gripping narratives that are sure to keep avid readers engaged. Get ready to discover the must-read mystery novels that will have you turning pages late into the night!
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
10. The Third Girl (Molly Sutton Mysteries Book 1)
$9.99 • 4 Stars • 6562 Reviews
The Third Girl (Molly Sutton Mysteries Book 1) takes readers on a thrilling journey through the quaint village of Castillac, France, where ex-Bostonian Molly Sutton seeks solace post-divorce. With a captivating setting rich in charm—think delightful croissants and exceptional wine—this novel juxtaposes the beauty of village life with the unsettling mystery of a missing girl, Amy Bennett. With a solid 4-star rating from over 6,500 reviews, it’s clear that fans appreciate its blend of relatable character development and engaging plot twists. The standout quality of this mystery is how effortlessly it immerses readers in the picturesque yet perilous life of the protagonist, who unexpectedly finds herself involved in solving the case alongside a local detective. Pros of this gripping tale include its well-crafted characters and an intricate narrative that keeps you guessing until the end. However, some readers may feel that the pacing could be uneven at times, which might detract from the suspense. This book is perfect for cozy mystery enthusiasts and fans of strong female leads, making it a must-read for anyone looking to escape into a world of intrigue and charm.
Discover the thrilling world of ‘The Third Girl’ – Click here to learn more!
9. Drive To Kill: FBI Mystery Thriller (Dean Blackwood FBI Mystery Thriller)
$0.00 • 4.3 Stars • 466 Reviews
If you’re in search of a gripping read to dive into, Drive To Kill: FBI Mystery Thriller (Dean Blackwood FBI Mystery Thriller) is a standout pick that seamlessly combines suspense and thrilling storytelling. With a stellar 4.3-star rating from 466 reviews, this novel has captivated a wide audience. The narrative follows a relentless FBI agent as they unravel a tangled web of deceit, peril, and unexpected twists, keeping you on the edge of your seat from start to finish. What makes it especially appealing is its accessibility, being offered at the enticing price of $0.00, making it an excellent introductory piece for readers looking to delve into the genre without any financial commitment. Pros include its fast-paced plot and character depth, which enriches the overall reading experience, while some cons highlight that occasional pacing issues might deter readers who prefer non-stop action. Best suited for fans of crime thrillers and mystery enthusiasts, this novel is a perfect companion for cozy evenings or long commutes, promising to keep you engrossed until the very last page.
Uncover the mystery—explore ‘Drive To Kill’ now!
8. Noble Beginnings: A Thriller (Jack Noble Book 1)
$9.54 • 4.1 Stars • 36684 Reviews
Delve into the thrilling world of suspense with ‘Noble Beginnings: A Thriller (Jack Noble Book 1),’ a gripping mystery novel that has captivated readers worldwide, boasting a solid star rating of 4.1 and over 36,000 reviews on Amazon. Priced affordably at $9.54, this page-turner introduces you to Jack Noble, an ex-marine and skilled assassin, who finds himself embroiled in a dangerous conspiracy after a simple mission spirals out of control. The author’s masterful storytelling combines fast-paced action, intriguing plot twists, and complex characters, making it perfect for fans of espionage and thrillers. Notable pros include its engaging narrative and well-developed protagonists, while a potential con is that some readers may feel the pacing could be rushed in certain sections. This novel is an ideal choice for avid readers who crave intense action and suspenseful plots, as well as those looking to immerse themselves in a new gripping series.
Dive into suspense with ‘Noble Beginnings: A Thriller’ – Get your copy now!
7. Shallow Waters: A Port Stirling Mystery Book 1
$13.79 • 4.4 Stars • 3303 Reviews
Shallow Waters: A Port Stirling Mystery Book 1 is a gripping police procedural that blends suspense, character depth, and a haunting coastal backdrop, making it a must-read for mystery enthusiasts. Set in the sleepy, rain-soaked town of Port Stirling, Oregon, this novel introduces Chief of Police Matt Horning, who encounters a shocking murder on his first day at work – the death of the mayor’s daughter, Emily Bushnell. With a solid star rating of 4.4 and over 3,300 reviews, readers rave about its brisk pacing and engaging narrative. The story dives deep into the mystery, revealing twisted plot elements, including human bite marks on the victim, which leave readers guessing until the last moment. The key features of this book include a vividly sketched setting, layered characters, and an intricate murder mystery that unravels with unexpected turns. Fans of thrillers and crime fiction will appreciate the blend of procedural elements with psychological tension, making it suitable for those who enjoy a complex narrative peppered with moral dilemmas. However, some may find the pacing a bit rushed at times, and the cliffhanger ending may leave readers eager for the next installment. Overall, ‘Shallow Waters’ is a standout choice for mystery lovers looking for depth and an engaging plot that keeps them on the edge of their seats.
Dive into the mystery of ‘Shallow Waters’ – Click here for details!
6. The Luckiest Woman Ever (Molly Sutton Mysteries Book 2)
$12.45 • 4.2 Stars • 3370 Reviews
The Luckiest Woman Ever (Molly Sutton Mysteries Book 2) is a thrilling addition to the Molly Sutton Mysteries series that has captivated readers with its engaging blend of suspense and charm. Set in the picturesque French village of Castillac, this novel follows the plucky amateur detective, Molly Sutton, as she stumbles upon a murder that uncovers dark secrets lurking within a lavish mansion. With a star rating of 4.2 based on over 3,370 reviews, it’s clear that readers are hooked by its gripping plot and clever twists. Priced at just $12.45, this mystery novel offers an exciting escape for those who love a good whodunit. The standout qualities include Molly’s resourcefulness, her ability to navigate the complexities of small-town life, and the vivid descriptions of the setting that transport readers right into the heart of Castillac. It’s particularly suited for fans of cozy mysteries looking for an engaging story with a strong female lead. Pros include its compelling character development and richly detailed setting, while cons might be its slower pacing in some areas. Overall, ‘The Luckiest Woman Ever’ is perfect for anyone seeking a delightful combination of intrigue and light-hearted moments.
Discover the mystery of ‘The Luckiest Woman Ever’ – Click for details!
5. A Flicker in the Dark: A Novel
$9.90 • 4.3 Stars • 60652 Reviews
A Flicker in the Dark: A Novel – A Must-Read for Mystery Enthusiasts Dive into the chilling world of A Flicker in the Dark, the debut novel from Stacy Willingham that has captured the hearts of over 60,000 readers, earning an impressive 4.3-star rating on Amazon. This psychological thriller follows Chloe Davis, a psychologist whose past is tainted by the traumatic disappearance of six teenage girls in her hometown, a tragedy that has shaped her life forever. Now, as she prepares for her wedding, Chloe is drawn back into a web of fear when local girls start going missing again. Willingham’s masterful storytelling delivers a fast-paced narrative brimming with unexpected twists that keeps you on the edge of your seat, making it nearly impossible to put the book down. Notable for its lyrical prose and character depth, the book explores themes of trauma, control, and the pursuit of happiness against a haunting backdrop. Pros: Gripping plot with unpredictable twists, strong character development, and a compelling narrative that will appeal to psychological thriller fans. Cons: Some readers may find the pacing slower at times, and the intense themes may not be suitable for all audiences. Ideal for anyone who loves intricate mysteries, psychological thrillers, or simply enjoys a good page-turner late into the night. Prepare to be captivated by Chloe’s journey as she unravels the shocking truths of her past in this tantalizing novel.
Discover the gripping world of ‘A Flicker in the Dark’ – click for details!
4. Then She Was Gone: A Novel
$9.51 • 4.5 Stars • 117619 Reviews
Looking for an enthralling mystery novel that you simply can’t put down? ‘Then She Was Gone: A Novel’ by Lisa Jewell is a top pick among avid readers, boasting an impressive star rating of 4.5 from over 117,000 reviews on Amazon. Priced at just $9.51, this gripping tale weaves together themes of love, loss, and the haunting mystery surrounding a missing daughter. The story follows Ellie, a mother whose life is turned upside down after her teenage daughter disappears, and it expertly unravels the emotional complexity of grief and the search for closure. Notable features include Jewell’s exquisite character development and a suspenseful plot that keeps readers guessing until the very end. Pros of this novel include its compelling narrative and relatable characters, while some readers have noted a slow build-up that may not suit everyone. Whether you’re a die-hard mystery lover or someone seeking a thought-provoking read, ‘Then She Was Gone’ is tailor-made for those who appreciate emotional depth alongside a captivating thriller!
Discover the gripping story of ‘Then She Was Gone’ – Click here to learn more!
3. Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone: A Novel (The Ernest Cunningham Mysteries Book 1)
$5.98 • 4 Stars • 10873 Reviews
If you’re looking for a mystery novel that will keep you on the edge of your seat, look no further than ‘Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone’ by renowned author Benjamin Stevenson. This cleverly crafted debut sets the stage for an unforgettable Christmas gathering aboard a train, where everyone is potentially a suspect and secrets are as common as holiday cheer. With over 10,000 reviews and a solid 4-star rating, this book has captivated readers with its sharp wit and engaging plot twists. Stevenson artfully mixes humor with suspense, making the characters relatable yet enigmatic. At a price point of just $5.98, this novel offers immense value, perfect for fans of whodunits and thrill-seekers alike. Notable pros include its intricate plot and well-developed characters that keep readers guessing until the end, while a potential con might be its unconventional narrative style that may not appeal to everyone. Ideal for lovers of psychological thrillers and family dramas, this book will not only entertain but will also give you something to ponder long after the last page is turned.
Discover the thrilling secrets of ‘Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone’!
2. The Thursday Murder Club: A Novel
$1.99 • 4.3 Stars • 161246 Reviews
The Thursday Murder Club: A Novel is a beguiling mystery that effortlessly combines humor and suspense, making it a must-read for fans of the genre. This New York Times bestseller, soon to be brought to life in a major motion picture by Steven Spielberg, introduces readers to four clever septuagenarians who meet weekly to solve unsolved crimes. Their camaraderie and quirky approaches to sleuthing are highlighted when they stumble into a real murder case involving a local developer. With its engaging plot and endearing characters, this novel receives a 4.3-star rating from over 161,000 reviews, reflecting its widespread appeal. Priced at just $1.99, it offers incredible value for an entertaining read that promises laughter, intrigue, and unexpected twists. Ideal for mystery lovers who appreciate wit and depth, The Thursday Murder Club captivates both casual readers and seasoned detectives alike, though some may find certain plot developments slightly implausible. Overall, it’s a delightful choice for anyone looking to enjoy a smart and amusing mystery.
Discover the mystery of The Thursday Murder Club!
1. The Frozen River: A GMA Book Club Pick: A Novel
$13.50 • 4.6 Stars • 47314 Reviews
Dive into the enthralling world of ‘The Frozen River: A GMA Book Club Pick: A Novel’ by Ariel Lawhon, a historical mystery that has captivated readers nationwide, earning a spot on The New York Times bestseller list and recognition as an NPR Book of the Year. Set in Maine in 1789, this gripping tale centers around Martha Ballard, an outspoken midwife who uncovers dark truths within her close-knit community when a man is found dead entombed in ice. With rich historical detail, Lawhon’s narrative explores themes of justice, female empowerment, and societal constraints, making it a must-read for fans of character-driven mysteries like ‘Outlander.’ Readers will appreciate Lawhon’s clever storytelling and her ability to weave Martha’s poignant diary entries into the narrative, which serve not only as a plot device but also as a historical lens into a woman’s life during a patriarchal era. Priced at $13.50 and boasting a stellar 4.6-star rating from over 47,000 reviews, this book appeals to mystery enthusiasts and history buffs alike. While the intricate plot may require careful attention to detail, the compelling characters and immersive storytelling ensure that this novel will be hard to put down. Whether you are a fan of historical fiction or simply looking for a powerful story of resilience and truth-seeking, ‘The Frozen River’ won’t disappoint.